Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Search By Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Classic
  • Twitter Classic
  • Google Classic

The War Against Cities

This piece was first published in The Hill on August 1, 2021. You can view that version here.


The Republican Party is waging a war against cities, especially those in the Northeast and on the West Coast that vote for Democrats and have large minority populations. The GOP gleefully rammed through provisions in its 2017 tax bill that limited federal deductions for state and local taxes and mortgage interest. Those changes were designed to hit cities and suburbs more than low-cost rural areas. Truth be known, federal expenditures largely financed by the taxes of wealthy northeastern and west coast cities and suburbs have long flowed disproportionately to rural Midwestern, Southern and Western states in the form of dams, waterway investments, highways that are toll-free, farm and fossil fuel tax breaks and subsidies. State legislatures, by the same token are skewed to favor rural areas, and Republicans at the federal and state level are working hard to make them even more so.


What is not well understood is that there is nothing new about the rural hostility to cities that we are seeing today in the U.S. Wealth is almost always the result of commerce and commerce is essentially urban. Cities are where the merchants are and therefore where the money is and disparities in wealth between urban and rural areas breed hostility. World history is full of clashes between city and rural peoples. In the 1980s, for example, I took my family on a revealing trip to Sweden. We rented a charming old farmhouse on the island of Gotland in the Baltic between Sweden and Poland. The house was only a few hundred yards from a crossroads where a trove of ancient silver coins from the Persian Gulf and Byzantium had recently been unearthed.


Gotland’s major city, Visby, was a prosperous trading center from the 1200s to the 1400s. It is a UNESCO World Heritage site, in part because it is enclosed by a brick and stone wall 30 feet high and two miles long with 27 large towers and a dozen smaller ones. Visby’s wall was not about protection from foreign invaders, and that is the point. When I asked the director of the city’s museum if the wall was to keep the Vikings out, his answer surprised me. No, the director said, the massive wall was not to keep the Vikings out. It was “to keep the farmers out.”